Elmer Davis Lake is one of the named reservoir waters in Owen County, so my first stop would be one easy-to-read part of the lake where I can understand the first adjustment before adding more tackle. I would start by learning one promising starting zone instead of trying to see the whole lake at once, because the first trip does not need to solve the whole lake.
Elmer Davis Lake Size, Maximum Depth and Volume
The known size and water figures for Elmer Davis Lake are about 148.8 surface acres and 4,650 acre-feet of storage, or roughly 1.5 billion gallons, which gives practical context for how much ground makes sense to fish while using the measurements to plan the day rather than dictate it.
Fish Species and Best Baits
Fish recorded for Elmer Davis Lake include Black Crappie, Bluegill, Brook Silverside, Channel Catfish, Common Carp, Flathead Catfish, Freshwater Drum, Gizzard Shad, Golden Redhorse, Golden Shiner, Grass Carp, and Green Sunfish, plus 11 additional recorded species, so I would choose one clear target until the first pattern develops so I can judge the first pattern without unnecessary noise. For largemouths at Elmer Davis Lake, I would start with a search bait and move to a jig or Texas rig as I get a feel for the opening section without carrying more tackle than I need.
A Practical Elmer Davis Lake Game Plan
On Elmer Davis Lake, I would begin around one nearby area near the launch with one clear target and change one part of the plan before the rest while keeping the day focused on learning instead of covering distance. The moment one manageable piece of water starts making sense on Elmer Davis Lake, I would let that clue shape the next move, which is enough progress for a productive first visit.
Nearby fishing waters
Explore nearby waters, including local Featured destinations. Check each page for access and fishing restrictions.
Distances are straight-line estimates between mapped water locations.